Philippe K Widmer, George Elias, Peter Zweifel, Improving efficiency through consolidation of jurisdictions? Evidence from the cantons of Switzerland, In: Working paper series / Department of Economics, No. 85, 2012. (Working Paper)
The purpose of this paper is to analyze the optimal scale of local jurisdictions (cantons) in Switzerland applying Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) to the years 2000 to 2004. Aggregate output performance indicators for four local government activities (administration, education, health, and transportation) are used to measure technical and scale efficiency and to derive DEA scores. Results show that these public services fail to exhibit economies of scale, undermining quests for centralization of public good provision while suggesting the possibility of Tiebout competition. |
|
Boris Krey, Philippe K Widmer, Peter Zweifel, Efficient Provision of Electricity for the United States and Switzerland, In: Working paper series / Socioeconomic Institute, No. No. 0812, 2011. (Working Paper)
This study applies financial portfolio theory to determine efficient frontiers in the provision of electricity for the United States and Switzerland. Expected returns are defined by the rate of productivity increase of power generation (adjusted for external costs), volatility, by its standard deviation. Since unobserved productivity shocks are found to be correlated, Seemingly Unrelated Regression Estimation (SURE) is used to filter out the systematic component of the covariance matrix of the productivity changes. Results suggest that as of 2003, the feasible maximum expected return (MER) electricity portfolio for the United States contains more Coal, Nuclear, and Wind than actual but markedly less Gas and Oil. The minimum variance (MV) portfolio contains markedly more Oil, again more Coal, Nuclear, and Wind but almost no Gas. Regardless of the choice between MER and MV, U.S. utilities are found to lie substantially inside the efficient frontier. This is even more true of their Swiss counterparts, likely due to continuing regulation of electricity markets. |
|
Philippe K Widmer, Peter Zweifel, Mehdi Farsi, Accounting for heterogeneity in the measurement of hospital performance, In: Working paper series / Department of Economics, No. No. 52, 2011. (Working Paper)
With prospective payment of hospitals becoming more common, measuring their performance is gaining in importance. However, the standard cost frontier model yields biased efficiency scores because it ignores technological heterogeneity between hospitals. In this paper, efficiency scores are derived from a random intercept and an extended random parameter frontier model, designed to overcome
the problem of unobserved heterogeneity in stochastic frontier analysis. Using a sample of 100 Swiss hospitals covering the years 2004 to 2007 and applying Bayesian inference, significant heterogeneity is found, suggesting rejection of the standard cost frontier model. Estimated inefficiency decreases even below the 14 percent reported by Hollingsworth (2008) for European countries. Accounting for unobserved heterogeneity would make hospitals rated below 85 percent efficiency according to the standard model gain up to 12 percentage points, serving to highlight the importance of heterogeneity correction in the estimation of hospital performance. |
|
Peter Zweifel, Swiss experiment shows physicians, consumers want significant compensation to embrace coordinated care, Health Affairs, Vol. 30 (3), 2011. (Journal Article)
Policy makers in several industrial countries are seeking to limit the rise in health care cost growth by supporting coordinated or integrated care programs, which differ from most prevailing forms of medical organization in how physicians are paid and how they work in groups. However, as long as fee-for-service payment systems remain an option, general practitioners will be reluctant to embrace coordinated care because it would give them less autonomy in how they practice. A study in Switzerland indicates that general practitioners will require a pay increase of up to 40 percent before they are willing to accept coordinated care, and a similar study found that Swiss consumers wanted a substantial reduction in premiums to accept it. These findings suggest that provisions of US health care reform designed to encourage the growth of coordinated care—such as accountable care organizations and medical homes—may face a challenging future. |
|
Janet MacNeil Vroomen, Peter Zweifel, Preferences for health insurance and health status: does it matter whether you are Dutch or German?, The European Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 12 (1), 2011. (Journal Article)
This contribution seeks to measure preferences for health insurance of individuals with and without chronic conditions in two countries, Germany and the Netherlands. The objective is to test the presumption that preferences between these two subpopulations differ and to see whether having a chronic condition has a different influence on preferences depending on the country. The evidence comes from two Discrete Choice Experiments performed in 2005 (Germany) and 2006 (the Netherlands, right after a major health reform). Results point to an even more marked resistance against restrictions of physician choice among individuals with chronic conditions in both countries. Thus, the alleged beneficiaries of Disease Management Programs would have to be highly compensated for accepting the restrictions that go with them. |
|
Philippe K Widmer, Peter Zweifel, Public Good Provision in a Federalist Country: Tiebout Competition, Fiscal Equalization, and Incentives for Efficiency in Switzerland, In: Working paper series / Socioeconomic Institute, No. No. 804, 2010. (Working Paper)
The purpose of this paper is twofold. First, it measures the efficiency in the provision of public goods by local jurisdictions applying Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). Second, it relates ef- ficiency scores to a fiscal equalization scheme designed to mitigate the negative consequences of Tiebout competition. The data come from the 26 cantons of Switzerland (2000-2004), a country characterized by marked federalism. Results show the equalization scheme to indeed have a negative influence on performance, resulting in an efficiency-equity trade-off (Stiglitz, 1988). However, substitution of earmarked payments by lump-sum payments as part of the 2008 reform is likely to enhance cantonal performance. |
|
Johannes Schoder, Michele Sennhauser, Peter Zweifel, Fine-tuning of health insurance regulation - unhealthy consequences for an individual insurer, International Journal of the Economics of Business, Vol. 17 (3), 2010. (Journal Article)
This paper sheds light on some unexpected consequences of health insurance regulation that may pose a big challenge to insurers' risk management. Because mandated uniform contributions to health insurance trigger risk-selection efforts, risk adjustment (RA) schemes become necessary. A good deal of research into the optimal RA formula has been performed. A recent proposal in Switzerland has been to add 'Hospitalization exceeding three days during the previous year' as an indicator of high risk. Applying the new formula to an individual Swiss health insurer, its payments into the RA scheme are predicted to increase substantially, reaching up to 13% of premium income. Its mistake had been to implement Managed Care successfully, resulting in low rates of hospitalization. The expected risk management response is to extend hospital stays beyond three days, contrary to stated policy objectives. |
|
Sule Akkoyunlu, Frank R Lichtenberg, Boriss Siliverstovs, Peter Zweifel, Spurious correlation in estimation of the health production function: A note, Economics Bulletin, Vol. 30 (3), 2010. (Journal Article)
In this paper, we address the issue of spurious correlation in the production of health in a systematic way. Spurious
correlation entails the risk of linking health status to medical (and nonmedical) inputs when no links exist. This note
first presents the bounds testing procedure as a method to detect and avoid spurious correlation. It then applies it to a
recent contribution by Lichtenberg (2004), which relates longevity in the United States to pharmaceutical innovation
and public health care expenditure. The results of the bounds testing procedure show longevity to be related to these
two factors. Therefore, the estimates reported by Lichtenberg (2004) cannot be said to be result of spurious
correlation, to the contrary, they very likely reflect an effective relationship, at least for the United States. |
|
Michele Sennhauser, Peter Zweifel, A Pharmaceutical Innovation - Is it Worth the Money? Whose Money?, In: Working paper series / Socioeconomic Institute, No. No. 914, 2010. (Working Paper)
This study seeks to provide evidence for deciding whether or not a pharmaceutical innovation should be included in the benefit list of social health insurance. A discrete choice experiment (DCE) was conducted in Germany to measure preferences for modern insulin therapy. Of the 1,100 individuals interviewed in 2007, 200 suffered from type 1 diabetes, 150 from insulin-treated type 2 diabetes, and 150 from insulin-naive type 2 diabetes. The long-acting insulin analogue ”Insulin Detemir” is compared to human insulin as the status quo. The DCE contains two price attributes, copayment and increased contributions to health insurance. As one would expect, non-affected non-diabetics and insulin-naive diabetics exhibit higher willingness-to-pay (WTP) values through copayment (adjusted for probability of contracting diabetes), while affected type 1 and insulin-treated type 2 diabetics have higher WTP through increased contributions. However, WTP values exceed the extra treatment cost in both financing alternatives, justifying inclusion of the innovation in the benefit list from a cost-benefit point of view. |
|
Peter Zweifel, Maria Trottmann, Maurus Rischatsch, Verbot der Selbstdispensation - ein widersprüchlicher Vorschlag, In: Neue Zürcher Zeitung, 156, p. 36, 9 July 2010. (Newspaper Article)
Die Medikamentenabgabe durch Ärzte ist umstritten. Im Folgenden wird dargelegt, dass ein Verbot wohl keine Kosteneinsparungen zeitigen dürfte. |
|
K Beck, Maria Trottmann, Peter Zweifel, Risk adjustment in health insurance and its long-term effectiveness, Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 29 (4), 2010. (Journal Article)
|
|
Patrick Eugster, Michele Sennhauser, Peter Zweifel, Capping risk adjustment?, Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 29 (4), 2010. (Journal Article)
When premiums are community-rated, risk adjustment (RA) serves to mitigate competitive insurers’ incentive to select favorable risks. However, unless fully prospective, it also undermines their incentives for efficiency. By capping its volume, one may try to counteract this tendency, exposing insurers to some financial risk. This in term runs counter the quest to refine the RA formula, which would increase RA volume. Specifically, the adjuster, “Hospitalization or living in a nursing home during the previous year” will be added in Switzerland starting 2012. This paper investigates how to minimize the opportunity cost of capping RA in terms of increased incentives for risk selection. |
|
Ilja Neustadt, Peter Zweifel, Is the Welfare State Sustainable? Experimental Evidence on Citizens' Preferences for Redistribution, In: Working paper series / Socioeconomic Institute, No. No. 1003, 2010. (Working Paper)
The sustainability of the welfare state ultimately depends on citizens’ preferences for income redistribution. They are elicited through a Discrete Choice Experiment performed in 2008 in Switzerland. Attributes are redistribution as GDP share, its uses (the unemployed, old-age pensioners, people with ill health etc.), and nationality of bene?ciary. Estimated marginal willingness to pay (WTP) is positive among those who deem bene?ts too low, and negative otherwise. However, even those who state that government should reduce income inequality exhibit a negative WTP on average. The major ?nding is that estimated average WTP is maximum at 21% of GDP, clearly below the current value of 25%. Thus, the present Swiss welfare state does not appear sustainable. |
|
Peter Zweifel, Karolin Leukert, Stephanie Berner, Preferences for Health Insurance in Germany and the Netherlands - A Tale of Two Countries, In: Working paper series / Socioeconomic Institute, No. No. 1002, 2010. (Working Paper)
This contribution contains an international comparison of preferences. Using two Discrete Choice Experiments (DCE), it measures willingness to pay for health insurance attributes in Germany and the Netherlands. Since the Dutch DCE was carried out right after the 2006 health reform, which made citizens explicitly choose a health insurance contract, two research questions naturally arise. First, are the preferences with regard to contract attributes (such as Managed-Care-type restrictions of physician choice) similar between the two countries? Second, was the information campaign launched by the Dutch government in the context of the reform effective in the sense of reducing status quo bias? Based on random-effects Probit estimates, these two questions can be answered as follows. First, while much the same attributes have positive and negative willingness to pay values in the two countries, their magnitudes differ, pointing to differences in preference structure. Second, status quo bias in the Netherlands is one-half of the German value, suggesting that Dutch consumers were indeed made to bear the cost of decision making associated with choice of a health insurance contract. |
|
Ilja Neustadt, Peter Zweifel, Economic Well-Being, Social Mobility, and Preferences for Income Redistribution: Evidence from a Discrete Choice Experiment, In: Working paper series / Socioeconomic Institute, No. No. 909, 2010. (Working Paper)
In this paper, preferences for income redistribution in Switzerland are elicited through a Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) performed in 2008. In addition to the amount of redistribution as a share of GDP, attributes also included its uses (working poor, the unemployed, old-age pensioners, families with children, people in ill health) and nationality of bene?ciary (Swiss, Western European, others). Willingness to pay for redistribution increases with income and education, contradicting the conventional Meltzer-Richard (1981) model. The Prospect of Upward Mobility hypothesis [Hirschman and Rothschild (1973); Benabou and Ok (2001)] receives partial empirical support. |
|
Rachel Kreier, Peter Zweifel, Health insurance in Switzerland: A closer look at a system often offered as a model for the United States, Hofstra Law Review, Vol. 39 (1), 2010. (Journal Article)
|
|
Peter Zweifel, Technologischer Wandel in der Medizin: Wie wird er durch die Bürgerinnen und Bürger bewertet?, In: Gesundheit und Wirtschaftswachstum : Recht, Ökonomie und Ethik als Innovationsmotoren für die Medizin, Springer, Berlin, p. 159 - 172, 2010. (Book Chapter)
|
|
Georg Erdmann, Peter Zweifel, Energieökonomik: Theorie und Anwendungen, Springer, Berlin, 2010. (Book/Research Monograph)
Die nachhaltige Lösung von Problemen der Energieversorgung gehört zu den zentralen Herausforderungen moderner Zivilisationen. Aus ökonomischer Sicht greifen alle Antworten zu kurz, die nicht explizit das interessengeleitete Handeln der wesentlichen Akteure berücksichtigen. Deshalb behandelt dieses Buch die nachfrage- und angebotsseitigen Gesetzmäßigkeiten der verschiedenen Energiemärkte, und zwar unter Rückgriff auf industrie- und institutionenökonomische Theoriebausteine. Die technisch-naturwissenschaftlichen Bedingungen von Gewinnung, Wandlung, Transport, Verteilung und Nutzung von Energieträgern werden dabei stets berücksichtigt. Ein wichtiges Thema für die Praktiker sind die von der Liberalisierung der leitungsgebundenen Energiemärkte ausgehenden Impulse. Wo immer möglich werden die heoretisch hergeleiteten Voraussagen durch die Konfrontation mit statistischer Evidenz auf ihre Praxisrelevanz geprüft. |
|
Stefan Felder, Andreas Werblow, Peter Zweifel, Do red herrings swim in circles? Controlling for the endogeneity of time to death, Journal of Health Economics, Vol. 29 (2), 2010. (Journal Article)
Studies on the effect of ageing on health care expenditure (HCE) have revealed the importance of controlling for time-to-death (TTD). These studies, however, are subject to possible endogeneity if HCE influences the remaining life expectancy. This paper introduces a 10-year observation period on monthly HCE, socioeconomic characteristics and survivor status to first predict TTD and then use the predicted values as an instrument in the regression for HCE. While exogeneity of TTD has to be rejected, core results concerning the role of TTD rather than age as a determinant of HCE (the ‘red herring’ hypothesis) are confirmed. |
|
Peter Zweifel, From theory to practice, In: Global marketplace for private health insurance: strength in numbers, World Bank, Washington, p. 107 - 140, 2009-11. (Book Chapter)
|
|