Mathilde Le Moigne, Simon Lepot, The distributional effects of carbon pricing: a global view of common but differentiated responsibilities, In: Kühne Center Impact Series, No. 02-23, 2023. (Working Paper)
In this Kühne Impact Series, we focus on the distributional effects of climate action. We simulate the distributional effects of a global carbon tax – the optimal economic policy tool in the fight against climate change – with or without international redistribution schemes. Our main result is that the economic costs of climate action are disproportionately borne by poor countries, but that realistic cross-country transfers could remedy this inequality. For example, annual North-South transfers of an average $200 per person would suffice to equalize the economic costs of climate action. |
|
M Scott Taylor, Optimal carbon tax for maritime shipping? Environmental policy meets network economics, In: Kühne Center Impact Series, No. 05-23, 2023. (Working Paper)
The world trading system is a very complicated network comprised of shipping routes that link many connecting ports or nodes. In such a networked setting, the economics of regulation is challenging because the efficiency of a networked system depends on both the set of active nodes (ports) and the volume of activity flowing through its links (trade). In this Kühne Impact Series, I discuss how a standard environmental policy such as taxing carbon emissions may have the unintended consequence of lowering overall network efficiency. As a result environmental policies need to be designed carefully whenever network interaction effects are large. When they are large and positive, as seems to be the case, then the optimal carbon tax is below the marginal social cost of carbon. |
|
Leonardo Bursztyn, Alexander W Cappelen, Bertil Tungodden, Alessandra Voena, David Yanagizawa-Drott, How are gender norms perceived?, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 41, 2023. (Working Paper)
Actual and perceived gender norms are key to understanding gender inequality in society. In this paper, using newly collected nationally representative datasets from 60 countries that cover over 80% of the world population, we study gender norms on two distinct policy issues: 1) basic rights, allowing women to work outside of the home, and 2) affirmative action, prioritizing women when hiring for leadership positions. We establish that misperceptions of gender norms are pervasive across the world. The nature of the misperception, however, is context-dependent. In less gender-equal countries, people underestimate support for both policies, particularly among men; in more gender-equal countries, people overestimate support for affirmative action, particularly among women, and underestimate support for basic rights. We provide evidence of gender stereotyping and overweighting of the minority view as potential drivers of the global patterns of misperceptions. Together, our findings indicate how misperceptions of gender norms may obstruct progress toward gender equality, but also may contribute to sustaining gender policies that are not necessarily favored by women themselves. |
|
Gary Charness, Ernst Fehr, Social preferences: fundamental characteristics and economic consequences, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 44, 2023. (Working Paper)
We review the vast literature on social preferences by assessing what is known about their fundamental properties, their distribution in the broader population, and their consequences for important economic and political behaviors. We provide, in particular, an overview of the empirically identified characteristics of distributional preferences and how they are affected by merit, luck, and risk considerations as well as by concerns for equality of opportunity. In addition, we identify what is known about belief-dependent social preferences such as reciprocity and guilt aversion. The evidence indicates that the big majority of individuals have some sort of social preference while purely self-interested subjects are a minority. Our review also shows how the findings from laboratory experiments involving social preferences provide a deeper understanding of important field phenomena such as the consequences of wage inequality on work morale, employees’ resistance to wage cuts, individuals’ self-selection into occupations and sectors that are more or less prone to morally problematic behaviors, as well as issues of distributive politics. However, although a lot has been learned in recent decades about social preferences, there are still many important, unresolved, yet exciting, questions waiting to be tackled. |
|
Thomas Epper, Ernst Fehr, Julien Senn, Social preferences across subject pools: students vs. general population, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 46, 2023. (Working Paper)
The empirical evidence on the existence of social preferences—or lack thereof—is predominantly based on student samples. Yet, knowledge about whether these findings can be extended to the general population is still scarce. In this paper, we compare the distribution of social preferences in a student and in a representative general population sample. Using descriptive analysis and a rigorous clustering approach, we show that the distribution of the general population’s social preferences fundamentally differs from the students’ distribution. In the general population, three types emerge: an inequality averse, an altruistic, and a selfish type. In contrast, only the altruistic and the selfish types emerge in the student population. We show that differences in age and education are likely to explain these results. Younger and more educated individuals—which typically characterize students—not only tend to have lower degrees of other-regardingness but this reduction in other-regardingness radically reduces the share of inequality aversion among students. Differences in income, however, do not seem to affect social preferences. We corroborate our findings by examining nine further data sets that lead to a similar conclusion: students are far less inequality averse than the general population. These findings are important in view of the fact that almost all applications of social preference ideas involve the general population. |
|
Thomas Epper, Ernst Fehr, Julien Senn, Social preferences and redistributive politics, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 47, 2023. (Working Paper)
Increasing inequality and associated egalitarian sentiments have put redistribution on the political agenda. In this paper, we take advantage of Swiss direct democracy, where people voted several times on strongly redistributive policies in national plebiscites, to study the link between social preferences and a behaviorally validated measure of support for redistribution in a broad sample of the Swiss population. Using a novel nonparametric Bayesian clustering algorithm, we uncover the existence of three fundamentally distinct preference types in the population: predominantly selfish, inequality averse and altruistic individuals. We show that inequality averse and altruistic individuals display a much stronger support for redistribution, particularly if they are more affluent. In addition, we show that previously identified key motives underlying opposition to redistribution – such as the belief that effort is an important driver of individual success – play no role for selfish individuals but are highly relevant for other-regarding individuals. Finally, while inequality averse individuals display strong support for policies that primarily aim to reduce the incomes of the rich, altruistic individuals are considerably less supportive of these policies. Thus, knowledge about the qualitative properties of social preferences and their distribution in the population also provides insights into which preference type supports specific redistributive policies, which has implications for how policy makers may design redistributive packages to maximize political support for them. |
|
Thomas Epper, Ernst Fehr, Julien Senn, The fundamental properties, stability and predictive power of distributional preferences, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 45, 2023. (Working Paper)
Parsimony is a desirable feature of economic models but almost all human behaviors are characterized by vast individual variation that appears to defy parsimony. How much parsimony do we need to give up to capture the fundamental aspects of a population’s distributional preferences and to maintain high predictive ability? Using a Bayesian nonparametric clustering method that makes the trade-off between parsimony and descriptive accuracy explicit, we show that three preference types—an inequality averse, an altruistic and a predominantly selfish type—capture the essence of behavioral heterogeneity. These types independently emerge in four different data sets and are strikingly stable over time. They predict out-of-sample behavior equally well as a model that permits all individuals to differ and substantially better than a representative agent model and a state-of-the-art machine learning algorithm. Thus, a parsimonious model with three stable types captures key characteristics of distributional preferences and has excellent predictive power. |
|
Anja Grob, Garret Binding, Judith Spirig, Introducing HESSS: home economics at Swiss secondary schools, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 40, 2023. (Working Paper)
Education policy has increasingly gained the attention of political scientists. Owing to its decentralised structure and the ensuing variation across cantons, the Swiss education system is a great place to study questions about the determinants and consequences of education policy. However, partly for the same reason, structured and detailed (historical) comparative data about curricula — who was was taught what, when, where and how — is relatively rare. We contribute to closing this gap by introducing HESSS, a novel dataset on the provision of home economics education (“Hauswirtschaft") in Switzerland in ten German-speaking cantons for vocational- and university track secondary schools since 1980 and 1991, respectively. The new dataset can help social science scholars explore variation in various aspects of home economics education over time and across cantons, and facilitate research on the Swiss educational system. In this research note, we outline the main features of the data and illustrate how it can be used in two applications: (i) tracking the switch from gender segregated to co-educated classes in response to the 1981 vote on equality for men and women; and (ii) describing the impact of cantonal education budget cuts and popular opposition to such cuts on home economics at secondary schools in the canton of Zurich. |
|
Michel Maréchal, Alain Cohn, Jeffrey Yusof, Raymond Fisman, Whose preferences matter for redistribution: cross-country evidence, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 42, 2023. (Working Paper)
Using cross-sectional data from 93 countries, we investigate the relationship between the desired level of redistribution among citizens from different socioeconomic backgrounds and the actual extent of government redistribution. Our focus on redistribution arises from the inherent class conflicts it engenders in policy choices, allowing us to examine whose preferences are reflected in policy formulation. Contrary to prevailing assumptions regarding political influence, we find that the preferences of the lower socioeconomic group, rather than those of the median or upper strata, are most predictive of realized redistribution. This finding contradicts the expectations of both leading experts and regular citizens. |
|
Samira Marti, Isabel Martínez, Florian Scheuer, Does a progressive wealth tax reduce top wealth inequality? Evidence from Switzerland, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 43, 2023. (Working Paper)
Like in many other countries, wealth inequality has increased in Switzerland over the last fifty years. By providing new evidence on cantonal top wealth shares for each of the 26 cantons since 1969, we show that the overall increase in concentration masks striking differences across cantons, both in levels and trends. Combining this with variation in cantonal wealth taxes, we then estimate an event study model to identify the dynamic effects of reforms to top wealth tax rates on the subsequent evolution of wealth concentration. Our results imply that a reduction in the top marginal wealth tax rate by 0.1 percentage points increases the top 1% (0.1%) wealth share by 0.9 (1.2) percentage points five years after the reform. This suggests that wealth tax cuts over the last 50 years explain roughly 18% (25%) of the increase in wealth concentration among the top 1% (0.1%). |
|
Reto Bürgisser, Fabienne Sarah Eisenring, Silja Häusermann, How perceived distributive effects shape labor market policy support, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 37, 2023. (Working Paper)
The growth of the knowledge economy alters the risks and opportunities citizens experience in the labor market. Governments attempt to steer and support the adaptation of the workforce, enhance and spread opportunities, and mitigate the negative implications of these changes, in particular via skill-developing labor market policies. However, many recent studies document a puzzling discrepancy between the needs of knowledge economy losers in terms of skill development and their policy preferences. In particular, those most threatened by the knowledge economy prioritize compensation and protection over investments in human capital. Our study theorizes and studies four mechanisms – two ego-tropic, one socio-tropic and one group-tropic – to explain this preference pattern: they a) may have distorted perceptions of the distributive effects of policy reforms, b) may assign less importance to human capital investment as opposed to transfers and protection, c) may think that investment reforms do not contribute to societal equality, or d) may feel that the reforms do not deliver social recognition for themselves and their social ingroups. To test the relative importance of these mechanisms, we analyze novel data from an original survey in nine European countries, using both observational and experimental evidence. Our findings provide evidence for the group-specific recognition mechanism. Knowledge economy losers do think that they would benefit from social investment, and they also think that investment would deliver on equality, but they do not perceive a distinctive benefit for themselves or their ingroups. In their eyes, compensation reforms are the only type of reforms that benefit their ingroups exclusively. Our findings suggest that the effectiveness of policy responses to the knowledge economy depends not only on material effects of reforms but is conditional on cultural and recognition-based mechanisms. |
|
Manuel Eisner, Denis Ribeaud, Giuseppe Sorrenti, Ulf Zölitz, The causal impact of socio-emotional skills training on educational success, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 36, 2023. (Working Paper)
We study the long-term effects of a randomized intervention targeting children’s socio-emotional skills. The classroom-based intervention for primary school children has positive impacts that persist for over a decade. Treated children become more likely to complete academic high school and enroll in university. Two mechanisms drive these results. Treated children show fewer ADHD symptoms: they are less impulsive and less disruptive. They also attain higher grades, but they do not score higher on standardized tests. The long-term effects on educational attainment thus appear to be driven by changes in socioemotional skills rather than cognitive skills. |
|
Tuomas Kari, And tracking for all: causes and effects of pupil sorting in middle school, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 38, 2023. (Working Paper)
Tracking, the policy of separating pupils into groups based on aptitude, is common, controversial and imperfectly understood. Little consensus exists on the circumstances under which tracking is practiced and what effects it may have on pupils. In this paper, I develop a novel method of measuring within-school tracking using observational data and estimate its long-run effects across a broad set of pupil outcomes. I show that tracking is prevalent, and that it varies both across schools and within schools over time. I find only limited evidence for tracking having significant short or long-run effects on pupils, although girls and boys seem to be affected differently. Finally, I provide evidence against the notion that tracking is a driver of inequality. |
|
Tuomas Kari, Lukas Leucht, Matteo Tranchero, Joosua Virtanen, Born to create and lead? The role of cognitive skills and personality traits for entrepreneurship and management, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 39, 2023. (Working Paper)
Founders exert large influence over their business ventures. Their cognitive skills and personality could explain management decisions and firm performance. Existing research suggests that while founders are selected on highly remunerated human capital, they often perform poorly in managing companies. There is little evidence for the mechanism behind this pattern. We investigate the role of cognitive and personality traits in determining who becomes an entrepreneur and how they manage their companies. We test for the presence of conflicting traits that both drive selection into founding and hinder managerial performance. Using comprehensive longitudinal data from Finnish administrative records combined with unique military data on cognitive skills and personality scores covering 80% of the male population, we first document how entrepreneurs stand out as intelligent and extroverted risk-takers. We confirm these findings in an event study on easing of financial constraints. Furthermore, we explore the descriptive and causal relationships between owner disposition and HR policy. This project has the potential to broaden our understanding of entrepreneurship dynamics and can inform the design of policies to encourage entrepreneurship. |
|
Tarik Abou-Chadi, Silja Häusermann, Tabea Palmtag, Stefanie Walter, Inequality perceptions: a research agenda, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 34, 2023. (Working Paper)
Many recent studies have underlined the importance of inequality perceptions as determinants of political demands and behavior. Yet, this literature often focuses on the public perception of one single, often economic, dimension of inequality. This study aims to broaden our perspective and provides a comprehensive assessment of public perceptions of socioeconomic (income, education, and class inequality) and sociocultural inequalities (gender, sexual orientation, and migration background inequality). Furthermore, we disentangle different components of inequality perceptions: the assessed importance of differences, as how problematic they are judged, and who thinks that these inequalities are central to political debates nowadays. We find that highly educated respondents attribute more importance and mostly judge inequalities across the board as more important than the less educated. While information on the extent of inequality can move the assessment of how important inequality is in society, the judgment of these divides remains unchanged, hinting to more deep-seated beliefs that are not as easily changed. |
|
Friedemann Bieber, Maurits de Jongh, Reconfiguring essential and discretionary public goods, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 29, 2023. (Working Paper)
When is state coercion for the provision of public goods justified? And how should the social surplus of public goods be distributed? Philosophers approach these questions by distinguishing between essential and discretionary public goods. This article explains the intractability of this distinction, and presents two upshots. First, if governments provide configurations of public goods that simultaneously serve essential and discretionary purposes, the scope for justifiable complaints by honest holdouts is narrower than commonly assumed. Second, however, claims to distributive fairness in the provision of public goods also turn out to be more complex to assess. |
|
Daniel Chachu, Michael Danquah, Rachel M Gisselquist, Subnational governance in Ghana: a comparative assessment of data and performance, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 31, 2023. (Working Paper)
In this chapter, we conceptualise an ideal framework that captures three reinforcing levers for measuring local government performance in sub-Saharan Africa, specifically Ghana, namely policy pronouncement, political processes and internal operations, and policy implementation. Given data limitations we employ a ‘next best’ approach to apply this framework and measure local government performance by combining a weighted ‘quality of reporting’ measure with selected available measures on political processes and internal operations, and policy implementation, so as to construct a composite index for local government performance (LGI). We also look at the relationship between our performance indices and other indices of local government performance in Ghana, as well as poverty headcounts. We find that, on average, urban districts perform better than their rural counterparts and also districts located in the southern half of Ghana perform better. Our constructed composite index is positively correlated with indices from Ghana’s district league tables. It has a negative relationship with poverty headcount in districts, indicating that districts with lower poverty incidence are more effective and responsive to their citizens. The findings provide a snapshot of institutional performance across Ghana’s districts, and offer a more comprehensive basis for considering variations in subnational institutional performance, including the effects of decentralisation than previous studies of Ghana – or indeed African countries more broadly. |
|
Joshua D Gottlieb, David Hémous, Jeffrey Hicks, Morten Olsen, The spillover effects of top income inequality, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 28, 2023. (Working Paper)
Top income inequality in the United States has increased considerably within occupations. This phenomenon has led to a search for a common explanation. We instead develop a theory where increases in income inequality originating within a few occupations can “spill over” through consumption into others. We show theoretically that such spillovers occur when an occupation provides non-divisible services to consumers, with physicians our prime example. Examining local income inequality across U.S. regions, the data suggest that such spillovers exist for physicians, dentists, and real estate agents. Estimated spillovers for other occupations are consistent with the predictions of our theory. |
|
Silja Häusermann, Tabea Palmtag, Delia Zollinger, Tarik Abou-Chadi, Stefanie Walter, Sarah Berkinshaw, Economic foundations of sociocultural politics: how new left and radical right voters think about inequality, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 33, 2023. (Working Paper)
Opposition between the far right and the new left has transformed West European politics, mainly through increasing sociocultural conflicts. We ask what the new cleavage articulated by these parties implies for the politicization of inequalities in advanced knowledge societies. We contrast two diverging expectations in existing literature: A first, more rational-choice-based perspective expects a trade-off, with new left voters "privileged" by economic transformations emphasizing sociocultural inequalities over socioeconomic ones–and vice versa for "disadvantaged" far right voters. A second, more sociological perspective, predicts attitudes on inequalities to be aligned along a single dimension from new left "universalists" being inequality-averse to right-wing "particularists" being more inequality-tolerant. Our evidence based on original survey data from Germany supports the second perspective. Studying the structural (educational, class, etc.) foundations of inequality aversion suggests that even the transformed (new) left electorate is more sensitive to all dimensions of inequality than voters on the (far) right. |
|
Geoffroy Legentilhomme, Matthieu Leimgruber, Richesse et pouvoir: les grandes fortunes zurichoises entre 1890 et 1952, In: URPP Equality of Opportunity Discussion Paper Series, No. 35, 2023. (Working Paper)
|
|